How To Choose: Convection Toaster Oven Vs Air Fryer
If youre having trouble choosing which type of air fryer to get, heres how wed decide.
Get the Cuisinart oven if:
- You have room in your kitchen for a larger oven.
- You have a family or larger household, and/or want to be able to cook larger portions of food at once.
- You want to make a variety of foods, such as baked goods, toast, frozen pizzas up to 13 inches, or roast chicken as big as 6 pounds.
- You want the option to adjust the convection fans speed or turn it off completely.
- You dont want to buy extra accessories to get the most out of your appliance.
- You dont mind turning your food to achieve even browning while cooking.
- You like to avoid nonstick coating, which lines the baskets in most pod-shaped air fryers and tends to wear off quickly.
- You want faster cleanup.
Get a pod-shaped air fryer if:
What To Look For In A Hybrid Toaster And Air Fryer Oven
Since you’re potentially going all-in on one machine, there are a few functions you want it to perform and perform well. For the purposes of this list, I took four main cooking functions into account: Air fry, broil, bake and toast. These, along with roast, are the oven duties the average home cook will rely on most. While some of these cookers sport dehydrate, proof, pizza and other niche cooking functions, most didn’t, so I stuck to testing functions that were possible across all the hybrid ovens.
Air frying: This trendy term has nothing to do with frying but rather mimics the results of deep-frying using super hot, fast-moving convection air for food that’s crispy outside and moist inside. Having an air fry function was the baseline criteria for consideration on this list. You can air fry lots of things, but chicken wings and french fries are two popular options, so I employed them for testing.
Broiling: I’m a big broiler person, especially for fish but also for things like mac and cheese, certain chicken recipes and anything else I want a crispy crust on top of. I find that ovens differ wildly in broiling ability so I wanted to see which of these ovens did it best.
Baking: Baking can mean a lot of things but when it comes to, let’s say cookies and cupcakes, consistency is key. The sign of an oven that bakes well is simple: Will it hit the temperature you set it to and then stay there consistently throughout the bake?
How We Tested Air Fryers
What is the first thing you think of when you consider air fryers? Chips, of course, so our homemade fries test was crucial.
The key to crisp fries was to peel and soak the potatoes in cold water for half an hour to remove starch, before drying thoroughly. We used Maris Piper potatoes for all.
We looked at the manuals for each model and followed their directions for cooking temperature, time and the quantity of oil needed. If the type of oil wasn’t specified them we used vegetable.
Anything from the size of the cut to the variety of potato can make a difference here, so its always good to gauge things halfway through the time. But for the purpose of the test, we shook ingredients only when prompted too and scored the appliance based on its performance.
We tested the air fryers using set criteria and scored each one on the following core areas out of five. The average of all determined the overall star rating they achieved:
Quality of foodTo ensure fairness, we initially cooked chips in every fryer we tested. We looked at how evenly they fried and whether they were brown and crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside.
Ease of useNo-one wants to resort to a YouTube video to work out how to use a new gadget. We looked for fryers with clear, simple instructions, so we could get them out of the box and cooking our dinner as quickly as possible. Fryers also scored highly if the icons or control buttons were easy to use and intuitive.
Don’t Miss: Gourmia Gta2500 Review
How Does Convection Oven Work
Convection ovens typically have two different parts: heat comes from above and one where hot air gets blown out . As the air heats up, it becomes less dense. This means the air is lighter and rises faster into the air vent above, where it continues to circulate around through adjustable fans that push air toward the food inside the oven. The hotter air then cooks surrounding food by not allowing hot air to collect directly above or touching food while still making sure air gets around every piece of food inside the oven.
Calphalon Performance Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo
The highlighted feature in this Calphalon device is its high contrast LCD screen to support you in reviewing and setting all feature controls. Besides, the black stainless-steel appearance will increase the modern look as well as its value to your kitchen.
Alright! Enough talking about its exteriors lets explore the amazingness inside the machine. First, the built-in Quartz Heat technology will produce 40% more heat to cook your food quicker and more effectively.
The Turbo Convection can ensure the air circulation around the food to cook them completely and evenly. You can choose any of 11 functions to create hearty treats. But if you select its air frying function, your meals are not only tasty but also have a perfect crispy finishing.
Here is an in-depth review to check the thermal precision of the Calphalon Performance air fryer.
Also Check: Jimmy Dean Sausage Biscuit In Air Fryer
Ninja Af 101 Air Fryer
The Ninja AF 101 air fryer is one of the best air fryers out there. I found it to have excellent ratings on almost all fronts.
From temperature regulation to user-friendliness and cooking capacity, this appliance excels. It doubles as a food hydrator and can be used to regulate the amount of liquid to be found in any food you are cooking with the air fryer.
The temperature accuracy is quite important because the appliance can be used either to remove moisture slowly or cook very fast with convection heat.
The appliance comes with four cooking functions to suit your fancy: air fry, roast, reheat and dehydrate.
Air Fryer Rotisserie Oven Combo 19 Qt Xl Convection Toaster Oven 10
This Air fryer oven is a product of the Wowchef brand. It is a 1800Watts digital oven that also performs the functions of a toaster and a dehydrator. It is a 10-in-1 multifunctional Air fryer that has a capacity of 19Qt.
The oven is a large one that weighs up to 20 pounds. It is a family-sized oven that requires little or no fat to cook with. It comes with nine accessories and a recipe book. The LED light makes the temperature and timing visible.
- It comes in a single colour.
Recommended Reading: Gourmia – 4.5qt Hot Air Fryer – Black/silver
What Is An Air Fryer Toaster Oven And Why Should You Choose It
There are various distinctions between toaster ovens and air fryers. Still, as the name suggests, an air fryer toaster oven combo combines these 2 appliances with all of their functions.
Therefore, you can simply understand this is a multi-tasking product to help you bake, roast, broil, air fry, etc., based on their built-in technology or models. These units are usually bigger than a basket-style air fryer with 2 to 3 rack levels inside.
The interior of an air fryer toaster oven looks pretty similar to a normal oven, and you cannot shake your food with this air fryer style. However, as the heating mechanism is on the top of the device, your dish on the top tends to be cooked quicker and crispier than those on the bottom.
In short, regardless of how many air fryers types, a significant factor that you can consider choosing an air fryer toaster oven is its versatility. You can apply different cooking methods with just one machine so you can save the kitchen space as well.
Air fryer vs. air fryer toaster oven who is the winner?
Is Air Frying Healthy
In comparison to deep-fat frying, air frying is a healthier alternative, since using convection cooking rather than oil means less fat in the finished food, which in turn means fewer calories. However, air frying does have some negatives, so it should be considered as part of a balanced diet. Read more about the health credentials of air fryers in our guide is air frying healthy?
Recommended Reading: Jimmy Dean Breakfast Burrito Cook Time
Dash Dcaf150gbgy02 Compact Air Fryer Oven Cooker With Temperature Control Non Stick Fry Basket Recipe Guide + Auto Shut Off Feature 2qt
The last item on our review list is this wonderful Dash product. It is designed in the most exclusive form with its cylindrical shape. This Dash DCAF150GBGY02 Oven uses the Air crisp technology to heat up food.
The Air fryer oven is both a combination of an oven and a cooker. It is a small 2Qt. capacity oven that can contain only 1lb of fries or other baked foods. It is made from durable stainless steel that can stand heat and pressure on the outside and a non-stick interior to avoid unhealthy cooking.
This oven comes in five colours and three styles. It can contain 1.2 litres of food and weighs up to 5.8 pounds. Also, it helps reduce fat and oil by up to 80%.
- It is portable and lightweight.
- It has an automatic shut off feature that stops overcooking.
- It cannot contain much food.
- It functions solely with electricity.
Best Unique Air Fryer Toaster Oven
You quite possibly never even thought that there could be such a thing as a unique air fryer toaster oven, but you’d be wrong. It’s okay, though: We didn’t know that there was such a thing until we did a little digging and came across the Ninja Foodi 9-in-1 Digital Air Fry Oven.
This little machine is compact, lightweight, and has one unique feature that we can confidently say the rest of these air fryers do not: its hinge. This air fryer can flip up and down, making it easy to use when you want to cook and less cumbersome when you want to move it. This air fryer will flip up right against your wall, giving you back precious countertop space and making it easier to clean.
If you like to use your air fryer for just about everything, this probably isn’t the air fryer for you, because it does lack cooking space. But if your kitchen is fully equipped and you only want the air fryer to replace a deep fryer, this is the product you’re after.
The Ninja Foodi 9-in-1 Digital Air Fry Oven is available on Amazon for $184.
Also Check: Chicken Cordon Bleu Bites Frozen
Which One Should I Buy
I am sure a lot of you are flicking through different products on Amazon wondering which to buy!! In this case, the decision to buy an air fryer or a conventional oven very much depends on your own personal situation. Maybe you have a very large family and always have to cook a lot. Maybe a traditional oven is for you. Maybe you are finding situations happening where you are heating up a big traditional oven just to cook a small batch of food. Then maybe an air fryer would become a valid and useful tool in your kitchen appliance arsenal.
The main reason we wrote this article is to lay out the key differences and advantages of each type of oven. This will hopefully help you make the right decision for your household.
Air-frying is a great addition to any modern kitchen. I know for me personally I use the air fry cooking method pretty much daily at this point.
If you have your own experiences with an air fryer, or have your own opinions about the proâs of these ovens, we would love to hear all about it in the comments section below.
We have done some other air fryer comparisons that might interest you. Click the text links below to go view them:
Best Compact Air Fryer Toaster Oven
Some of us don’t need to cook an entire rotisserie chicken in our air fryer toaster ovens. We just want them for chicken wings and fries, and maybe some slices of toast. If that’s you, you need the DeLonghi Livenza 9-in-1 Digital Air Fry Convection Toaster Oven.
This thing really does do it all. You won’t be able to cook more than one thing at once unless you split up space in the basket, but you will be able to cook many different foods because of its different presets.
This is a heavy appliance, so you won’t be able to move it around a lot on your countertop, but you won’t really need to since it’s so compact. If you have a small kitchen but still want an air fryer toaster oven, check out the DeLonghi Livenza.
You can buy the DeLonghi Livenza 9-in-1 Digital Air Fry Convection Toaster Oven on Amazon for $208.
Recommended Reading: Jimmy Dean Croissant In Air Fryer
Best Air Fryers In 2022
The experts we spoke to said that an air fryer should provide at least 2 quarts of cooking space for one or two people or at least 6 quarts for larger parties. They also said that the appliance should be easy to clean or have dishwasher-safe parts and come with a warranty of at least one year in case something breaks. With this advice in mind, we rounded up some pod-shaped air fryers and convection oven air fryers that experts love, as well as a couple bestsellers that received especially high marks from customers.
Which One Is Faster
Due to the way they work, most air fryers should be set to around 20-30C cooler than regular ovens, with the overall cooking time reduced by about 20 per cent. This rough guide is based on reading things like packet instructions for regular fan ovens. If youre using a dedicated air fryer recipe , then theres no need to convert anything.
Its important to note that while air fryers are faster, youll need to open the drawer and shake up the basket contents at least once during a cook to ensure even, crisp results for every item. This means that you might find yourself babysitting food while it cooks instead of simply walking away and letting it do its thing.
Also Check: Club Chefman Air Fryer Recipes
Crownful 106 Liter 10
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.1 total vote
This multifunctional convection toaster air fryer combo is an ideal gift for moms, dads, grandparents, or anybody who loves to cook and wants to have a healthier lifestyle. This air fryer Oven allows you to cook your favorite fried foods with little to no oil and without the mess that comes with deep frying
- Primary Material: Plastic
Breville Bov900bss Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo
Breville BOV900BSS is another great alternative for a traditional oven or deep fryer. And 13 cooking modes allow you to maximize your culinary ideas most easily.
But the best thing about this appliance is its huge capacity in which you can put a 14-pound turkey to feed your big household. Also, the Element iQ system with smart steer power can illustrate the best cooking performance and offer you evenly-cooked meals.
On the other hand, among many ideal air fryer dehydrators on the market, Breville BOV900BSS will show you the perfection in dehydration as you can put up to 4 trays to dehydrate your fruits or veggies.
- 13 programs consisting of pizza, cookies, bagel, air fry, toast, bake, roast, warm, proof, reheat, broil, slow cook, and dehydrate functions
- Advanced technology with Element iQ system to ensure the best cooking temperature and environment
- Super large capacity that can even hold a 14-pound turkey, 9 x 13-inch pan and a 12-muffin tray, 9 slices of bread, or a 5-quart Dutch oven
- Smart Oven Air with 2 speedy fans for superb results
- Smart LCD display to better read and choose functions
- Several accessories included
Still the Breville BOV900BSS work well after 11 months of use? Lets check here!
Recommended Reading: America’s Test Kitchen Deep Fryer
What Is An Air Frying Oven
By now, were all relatively well-versed in the world of air frying, including which air fryers are the best, what recipes you should cook in them and potentially, most importantly whether or not they really are the secret to healthier eating.
Overall, an air fryer functions by crisping and cooking food with circulated, heated air with little-to-no oil compared to typical deep frying. While countertop air fryers are great for quickly preparing smaller batches of food or cooking without heating up your kitchen, they’re not ideal for big-batch cooking or air frying an entire turkey for example. This is where an air fryer oven comes into play. You can achieve the same results you love from a countertop air fryer in your oven which gives you another level of versatility.
Best Expensive Air Fryer Toaster Oven
If you’re looking to buy an air fryer toaster oven and aren’t concerned with the price, look no further than the KitchenAid Dual Convection Countertop Oven. This is a fantastic option for countertop ovens, and could’ve easily been our overall pack if it weren’t for the higher price.
The Dual Convection Countertop Oven comes with a wire rack, baking pan, and basket, and has a removable crumb-catching sheet that fits underneath and can be easily pulled out to clean. With just a couple of buttons and knobs, you can run this machine with ease and choose from its 12 different cooking functions, including toast and dehydrate. Its many presets make it one of the most versatile machines on the market.
You can do virtually anything with this countertop oven and will love its simple functionality. If you can justify the price, the KitchenAid Dual Convection Countertop Oven with Air Fryer is a fantastic option.
You can buy the KitchenAid Dual Convection Countertop Oven on Amazon for $360.
Recommended Reading: How To Cook Jimmy Dean Breakfast Sandwich In Air Fryer